If police refuse to register an FIR about a cognizable offence, the ordinary statutory route is to send a written complaint to the Superintendent of Police and, if the grievance remains unresolved, approach the jurisdictional Magistrate. Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), the relevant provisions are Sections 173(4) and 175(3). An application seeking a Magistrate’s direction for investigation must be supported by an affidavit.

Why Sakiri Vasu remains relevant

In Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P., (2008) 2 SCC 409, decided on 7 December 2007, the Supreme Court considered a father’s request for a CBI investigation into his Army-officer son’s death. The Court declined that request and explained the remedies available when police do not register an FIR or investigate properly.

The judgment recognised the Magistrate’s power under Section 156(3) CrPC to direct registration and proper investigation, and to monitor compliance without personally investigating. It also explained that a complainant cannot insist on an investigating agency of their choice.

CrPC and BNSS: which sections apply?

Older judgments use CrPC numbering. The corresponding BNSS provisions relevant here are:

  • Complaint to the Superintendent of Police: Section 154(3) CrPC corresponds to Section 173(4) BNSS.
  • Magistrate-directed police investigation: Section 156(3) CrPC corresponds to Section 175(3) BNSS.
  • Examination of a private complainant: Section 200 CrPC corresponds to Section 223 BNSS.

These provisions include procedural changes, so changing section numbers alone is insufficient. Section 531 BNSS also preserves the CrPC procedure for specified proceedings pending at commencement. The procedural history of the case must be checked.

First, record the complaint and the police response

Prepare a factual account giving the date, place, people involved and available supporting material. Keep a copy of what you submitted and any acknowledgement or response. A complaint must disclose facts constituting an offence; describing a disagreement as criminal does not itself establish that an FIR is required.

Section 173 BNSS addresses information about cognizable offences, including information concerning an incident outside the station’s area. It also permits a preliminary inquiry in the specified category of offences punishable with three years or more but less than seven years, with prior permission from an officer of at least Deputy Superintendent rank, to ascertain a prima facie case within fourteen days.

Step 1: send a written complaint to the Superintendent of Police

Section 173(4) BNSS provides for sending the substance of the information in writing and by post to the Superintendent of Police concerned. Explain the incident, identify the police station approached and describe the refusal or inaction.

Attach copies of the earlier complaint and relevant records. Keep the postal receipt and delivery record with your copy. These documents help establish what information was supplied and the steps already taken. The representation should make the factual grievance clear without adding allegations that the available material cannot support.

Step 2: approach the Magistrate under Section 175(3) BNSS

If the grievance remains unresolved, the next ordinary remedy is an application to the Magistrate having jurisdiction, supported by an affidavit and the record of the earlier approach to police. A direction for investigation requires judicial consideration; it does not follow automatically from filing an application.

In XXX v. State of Kerala, 2026 INSC 88, the Supreme Court discussed the affidavit requirement, the Magistrate’s inquiry and consideration of police submissions. It also addressed the additional procedure under Section 175(4) where a complaint against a public servant concerns the discharge of official duties.

Where an FIR already exists, identify the particular omissions in investigation and the procedural stage. A request about investigative inaction should explain what material or issue has been overlooked.

Is a private complaint another option?

A private criminal complaint before the competent Magistrate is another available route. Section 223 BNSS governs examination of the complainant and contains its own procedural safeguards. It should not be presented as a compulsory final step after every investigation application. The suitable route depends on the allegations, the evidence available and the orders already passed.

Can you go directly to the High Court or demand a CBI investigation?

Sakiri Vasu says High Courts should ordinarily direct complainants to the available statutory remedies for FIR and investigation grievances. It also expressly recognises that an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to a writ petition. The ordinary sequence should therefore not be described as an inflexible ban on High Court relief.

The judgment distinguishes a proper investigation from a right to choose the agency. Constitutional courts can direct a CBI investigation in exceptional circumstances; such a direction is not a routine remedy for dissatisfaction with local police.

Documents to organise before seeking a remedy

A clear file helps a lawyer assess the allegations, jurisdiction and procedural history. Depending on the incident, useful material can include:

  • The original complaint, with its date and supporting documents.
  • Police acknowledgements, diary references and written replies.
  • The SP representation, postal receipt and delivery record.
  • Relevant messages, transaction records, photographs or medical documents.
  • Witness details and a brief chronology separating facts from suspicions.
  • Any existing FIR, police report or court order.

For a matter arising in Jabalpur or elsewhere in Madhya Pradesh, the competent police authority and court follow the facts and jurisdiction of the case. The related practice pages below describe the firm’s criminal-law and writ work.

This website version expands the author’s original article with BNSS references and practical explanations. The central lesson remains to document the grievance, use the applicable statutory remedy and identify the relief justified by the facts.

Case reference: Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P., (2008) 2 SCC 409; XXX v. State of Kerala, 2026 INSC 88