In Pradeep Kumar Lal vs. State of MP (WP No. 31235/2024, decided 14.05.2025), Justice Vishal Dhagat addressed a question that had created real uncertainty for litigants: should orders passed by revenue authorities under the M.P. Land Revenue Code, 1959 be challenged under Article 226 or Article 227 of the Constitution?
The background
An earlier Division Bench ruling (Babulal vs. Rajveer Singh, R.P. No. 869/2021) had held that since revenue authorities are not “subordinate courts,” only Article 226 petitions would lie against their orders — not Article 227. This created confusion in pending matters and even led to a reference to a Larger Bench on related questions.
What the Court held
Justice Dhagat found that the Babulal judgment gave no reasoning for concluding revenue authorities aren’t subordinate to the High Court — and that it overlooked binding precedent. Relying on:
- Dangalia vs. Deshraj (1973 MPLJ 796), which held that Section 31 of the MPLRC confers “Court” status on the Board of Revenue and Revenue Officers, and
- S.K. Sarkar vs. Vinay Chandra (1981 SCC 436), where the Supreme Court held that revenue courts are judicially subordinate to the High Court even without administrative control under Article 235,
the Court concluded that revenue authorities, being “Courts” subordinate to the High Court, are properly challenged through Article 227 (supervisory jurisdiction) — not Article 226 (original jurisdiction, generally for orders of Government/statutory authorities exercising public duty, not subordinate courts).
The takeaway
Orders passed by the Board of Revenue or Commissioners under the MPLRC — in second appeal, revision, or otherwise — should be challenged via petitions under Article 227. The Court even directed the Registry not to raise objections where such petitions are filed under Article 227.